Is China Airlines safe?
China Airlines
Taiwan's flag carrier had one of the worst records in the world between 1994 and 2002, with four fatal crashes. It has had no fatal accident since, and its fleet is modernising. Recent incidents, including a 2025 fine over an engine-failure diversion and a wrong-runway landing, keep the score down.
- Last crash with deaths
- CI611, Boeing 747, Taiwan Strait, 25 May 2002 (225 killed)
- Hull losses in 20 years
- 1 (CI120, Boeing 737-800 fire at Okinawa, 2007, no deaths)
- Fleet
- 87 aircraft, 69 passenger and 18 freighters (end of 2025)
- Main types
- Airbus A350-900, A321neo, Boeing 777-300ER, A330-300
- Home regulator
- Civil Aviation Administration, Taiwan (FAA FAA IASAThe US FAA's check of whether a country's aviation regulator meets ICAO standards. Category 1 means it does; Category 2 means it does not.More in the glossary)
- IOSA
- Registered (IATA member)
- Group airlines
- Mandarin Airlines and Tigerair Taiwan, separate certificates
How the score breaks down
The overall score is the weighted average of these factors. Scoring rules
Accident record40% of score
84 out of 100, GoodNo fatal accident since CI611 broke up over the Taiwan Strait in 2002 (225 killed), after crashes at Nagoya in 1994, Taipei in 1998 and Hong Kong in 1999. The only Hull lossAn accident in which an aircraft is destroyed or damaged beyond economic repair. People may or may not be hurt.More in the glossary in 20 years was CI120, a 737-800 that burned out at Okinawa in 2007 after everyone got off.
Regulatory oversight20% of score
84 out of 100, GoodTaiwan holds FAA IASAThe US FAA's check of whether a country's aviation regulator meets ICAO standards. Category 1 means it does; Category 2 means it does not.More in the glossary Category 1 (April 2025), no Taiwanese airline is on the EU Air Safety ListThe European Commission's list of airlines banned or restricted from flying in EU airspace because they do not meet international safety standards.More in the glossary (June 2026), and China Airlines is IOSAThe IATA Operational Safety Audit, an international audit of an airline's safety management and operations. Every IATA member must pass it.More in the glossary. Taiwan is outside ICAO and has no ICAO audit score; the CAA does fine airlines for operational lapses.
Fleet15% of score
76 out of 100, Good87 aircraft at the end of 2025 (annual report), with 15 A350-900s and 21 A321neos. Leased A330-300s and 737-800s from 2012–2016 are being returned, and eight 747-400 freighters remain. The company publishes no average age.
Serious incidents15% of score
66 out of 100, FairIn April 2025, an A350 flew three hours back to Kaohsiung on one engine; the CAA fined the airline NT$600,000 for not using a nearer airport. In June 2025, a 737-800 landed on the wrong runway at Busan. An A330 struck its tail landing at Taipei in 2016.
Operating environment10% of score
84 out of 100, GoodTaoyuan is a modern hub, but typhoons, monsoon storms and Taiwan's mountains complicate operations, and the regional network includes difficult airports such as Busan.
Is China Airlines safe?
Yes, today it is. China Airlines has not had a fatal accident since 2002, and most of its passenger fleet is now A350s, A321neos and 777s. We score it 80. The score is lower than EVA Air's 87 for two reasons: a Hull lossAn accident in which an aircraft is destroyed or damaged beyond economic repair. People may or may not be hurt.More in the glossary in 2007 that still sits inside our 20-year window, and a set of recent operational lapses that Taiwan's regulator has had to act on.
The 1990s and the turnaround
China Airlines' reputation was made in eight bad years. On 26 April 1994, an Airbus A300 landing at Nagoya stalled after the first officer accidentally triggered go-around mode and the pilots fought the autopilot; 264 of 271 people died. On 16 February 1998, another A300 came in too high at Taipei, went around, pitched up and stalled, killing all 196 on board. On 22 August 1999, an MD-11 crashed while landing at Hong Kong in a tropical storm, killing three.
The last fatal crash came on 25 May 2002. CI611, a Boeing 747-200, broke up at cruise altitude over the Taiwan Strait, and all 225 people died. Taiwan's investigators traced it to metal fatigue under a doubler fitted after a Tail strikeWhen the tail of an aircraft touches the runway during take-off or landing, usually because the nose was raised too far or too early.More in the glossary in 1980. The repair had not followed Boeing's structural repair manual.
What changed afterwards is visible in the record. In the 24 years since CI611, no passenger has died on a China Airlines flight. The difference from the 1990s is large: the airline went from four fatal crashes in eight years to none in 24.
CI120: the one hull loss since
On 20 August 2007, a Boeing 737-800 arriving at Okinawa's Naha airport from Taipei caught fire on the stand. Ground staff saw fuel pouring from the right wing; the crew shut down and all 165 people got out before the aircraft exploded and burned. Japan's investigators found that a part of the slat mechanism had most likely come loose after maintenance work about six weeks earlier, fallen into the slat track housing and punctured it when the slats retracted. It was a maintenance error, and the evacuation was a success.
Recent incidents and fines
The last two years show where China Airlines still has work to do.
- CI753, 13 April 2025. An Airbus A350-900 flying from Taipei to Singapore shut down its right engine at 39,000 feet over the South China Sea, about 220 nautical miles north-east of Nha Trang. Instead of landing at a nearer airport, the crew flew about three hours back to Kaohsiung. In September 2025 the Civil Aviation Administration (CAA) ruled that the airline had made a procedural error in choosing where to divert, breaking the flight-operations rules by not landing at the nearest suitable airport, and fined it NT$600,000.
- CI186, 12 June 2025. A Boeing 737-800 cleared to land on runway 18R at Busan landed on 18L instead. Korea's investigation board opened a case, with Taiwan's Transportation Safety Board (TTSB) taking part.
- Earlier events: an A330 Tail strikeWhen the tail of an aircraft touches the runway during take-off or landing, usually because the nose was raised too far or too early.More in the glossary landing at Taipei with a first officer in training (2016), and a 747 freighter that touched down short of the runway at Taipei in 2018.
None of these hurt anyone. But a long single-engine flight that the regulator thought was unnecessary, and a landing on the wrong runway, are the kind of lapses that a 1990s-scarred airline should be most careful to avoid.
The fleet
At the end of 2025, China Airlines had 87 aircraft: 69 passenger jets and 18 freighters (eight 747-400Fs and ten 777Fs), according to its annual report. Since late 2021, 21 A321neos have replaced most of the Boeing 737-800s on regional routes. Long-haul flights use 15 A350-900s and Boeing 777-300ERs, and A330-300s still fly many regional routes; their leases end between 2026 and 2028.
New aircraft are coming: Boeing 787s from 2026, then 15 A350-1000s, 15 Boeing 777-9s and 8 777-8 freighters from about 2029. China Airlines does not publish an average fleet age, so we score the fleet on its mix.
Flying China Airlines safely
- Check the aircraft type on regional routes. An A321neo or A350 is newer than the A330-300s and the few remaining 737-800s.
- Belt on, all flight. Turbulence during typhoon season and over the South China Sea is the most likely way to be hurt.
- Know the group airlines. Mandarin Airlines flies many domestic and short regional routes; Tigerair Taiwan is the group's low-cost airline. Both have their own certificates.
How we scored it
The accident record (84) reflects 24 years without a fatal crash, minus the 2007 Okinawa Hull lossAn accident in which an aircraft is destroyed or damaged beyond economic repair. People may or may not be hurt.More in the glossary. Oversight (84) and environment (84) match EVA Air. Serious incidents (66) are the weakest factor. Compare Korean Air, another airline that rebuilt its safety record after the 1990s.
Questions people ask
Is China Airlines the same as Air China?
No. China Airlines is Taiwan's flag carrier, based in Taipei, with the codes CI and CAL. Air China is the flag carrier of the People's Republic of China, based in Beijing (CA). They have different regulators, fleets and safety records.
What caused the China Airlines CI611 crash?
On 25 May 2002, a Boeing 747-200 broke up in flight near the Penghu islands on its way to Hong Kong, killing all 225 people. Taiwanese investigators traced it to metal fatigue around a repair made after a Tail strikeWhen the tail of an aircraft touches the runway during take-off or landing, usually because the nose was raised too far or too early.More in the glossary in 1980; the repair had not followed Boeing's manual. The aircraft was flying its last day for China Airlines.
Why did China Airlines have so many crashes?
Between 1994 and 2002, four fatal crashes killed 688 people on board, plus 7 on the ground at Taipei in 1998. The Nagoya (1994) and Taipei (1998) crashes involved crews losing control of an A300 during or near a go-around, and CI611 came from a faulty structural repair. They pointed to weak training, crew coordination and maintenance. The airline has had no fatal accident since 2002.
Is China Airlines safe to fly now?
Yes. It has gone 24 years without a fatal accident, is IOSAThe IATA Operational Safety Audit, an international audit of an airline's safety management and operations. Every IATA member must pass it.More in the glossary and flies a fleet that is now mostly A350s, A321neos and 777s. We score it 80, below EVA Air's 87, mainly because of its older history and recent operational lapses.
Are Mandarin Airlines and Tigerair Taiwan part of China Airlines?
Yes, both belong to the China Airlines group but fly under their own certificates; Mandarin mostly on domestic and short regional routes, Tigerair Taiwan as a low-cost airline. This page scores China Airlines mainline only.
Sources
- 1.ASN Wikibase 323047 – China Airlines CI611, Penghu, 25 May 2002 (opens in a new tab) · Aviation Safety Network, 2002
- 2.ASN Wikibase 321897 – China Airlines CI120, Okinawa-Naha, 20 August 2007 (opens in a new tab) · Aviation Safety Network, 2007
- 3.ASN Wikibase 324023 – China Airlines CI676, Taipei, 16 February 1998 (opens in a new tab) · Aviation Safety Network, 1998
- 4.China Airlines 2025 Annual Report (English) (opens in a new tab) · China Airlines / TWSE, 2026
- 5.China Airlines A359 over South China Sea on Apr 13th 2025, engine shut down in flight (opens in a new tab) · AeroInside, 2025
- 6.華航發動機故障疑捨近求遠轉降高雄爭議 民航局開罰60萬 (opens in a new tab) · United Daily News, 2025
- 7.China Airlines B738 at Busan on Jun 12th 2025, landed on wrong runway (opens in a new tab) · AeroInside, 2025
- 8.IASA Program Results (April 2025) (opens in a new tab) · FAA, 2025