Is Jazz Aviation safe?
Jazz Aviation
Jazz flies most Air Canada Express routes. In March 2026 one of its CRJ-900s hit a fire truck that controllers had cleared across the runway at LaGuardia, killing both pilots. Before that it had no fatal accident since forming in 2001, though two aircraft were written off in ground and landing accidents.
- Last fatal accident
- Flight 646 (AC8646), LaGuardia, 22 March 2026 (2 crew killed)
- Other hull losses
- CRJ100, Toronto, 2007; Dash 8-300, Toronto, 2019 (no deaths)
- Fleet flying for Air Canada
- 32 Dash 8-400s, 30 CRJ-900s, 25 E175s (June 2026)
- Owner
- Chorus Aviation
- Contract
- Air Canada capacity purchase agreement to 2035
- Regulator
- Transport Canada (FAA FAA IASAThe US FAA's check of whether a country's aviation regulator meets ICAO standards. Category 1 means it does; Category 2 means it does not.More in the glossary)
- IOSA
- Registered since 2005; current status not confirmed
How the score breaks down
The overall score is the weighted average of these factors. Scoring rules
Accident record40% of score
74 out of 100, GoodOn 22 March 2026 a Jazz CRJ-900 struck an airport fire truck while landing at LaGuardia and both pilots died (NTSB DCA26MA161). Investigators point at the truck's runway clearance. Jazz also wrote off a CRJ100 in 2007 and a Dash 8 in 2019, with no deaths.
Regulatory oversight20% of score
85 out of 100, ExcellentTransport Canada certifies Jazz and Canada holds FAA IASAThe US FAA's check of whether a country's aviation regulator meets ICAO standards. Category 1 means it does; Category 2 means it does not.More in the glossary Category 1. Jazz says it has held IOSAThe IATA Operational Safety Audit, an international audit of an airline's safety management and operations. Every IATA member must pass it.More in the glossary since April 2005, but it is not an IATA member and we could not confirm its current registry entry.
Fleet15% of score
68 out of 100, FairJazz flies CRJ-900s, Dash 8-400s and Embraer E175s, regional types from the 2000s and 2010s (Chorus Q2 2026 MD&A). Only the E175 has partial Fly-by-wireA flight control system in which the pilot's inputs go to computers, which then move the control surfaces. Many such systems also stop unsafe manoeuvres.More in the glossary controls, and the fleet is shrinking as older aircraft leave the Air Canada contract.
Serious incidents15% of score
76 out of 100, GoodA Dash 8 hit a fuel truck while taxiing at Toronto in 2019 and was Hull lossAn accident in which an aircraft is destroyed or damaged beyond economic repair. People may or may not be hurt.More in the glossary, with 5 people hurt. In 2017 a Dash 8 landed at more than 5.5 g at Billy Bishop and flew again before the damage was found (ASN, TSB).
Operating environment10% of score
76 out of 100, GoodJazz flies into busy, tight airports such as LaGuardia and Toronto Billy Bishop, and to many small Canadian airports with winter weather and fewer approach aids, such as Sault Ste. Marie, Gaspé and Grande Prairie.
Is Jazz Aviation safe?
Jazz is a safe airline with one fatal accident in its history, and that accident appears to have been caused largely outside the aircraft. We score it 76, below Air Canada at 84 and close to American Airlines. Most passengers never see the Jazz name: it flies the Air Canada Express routes, sold with AC flight numbers, between Canadian cities and to the US.
Jazz was formed in 2001 from Air Canada's regional airlines and is now owned by Chorus Aviation. It flies under its own Transport Canada certificate, with its own pilots and maintenance, under a contract with Air Canada that runs to 2035. Because of that, we score it separately and do not count its accidents against Air Canada, just as we treat Envoy or SkyWest separately from American and United.
The LaGuardia collision
On 22 March 2026, Jazz flight 646 from Montreal, a CRJ-900 sold as Air Canada 8646, was landing on runway 4 at LaGuardia at 23:37 with 72 passengers and four crew. A convoy of airport fire vehicles was heading across the airfield to a United jet that had reported a smell in its cabin.
According to the NTSB's preliminary report, the tower cleared the jet to land about two minutes before touchdown. The convoy's first radio call was blocked by another transmission. When the controller did clear "Truck 1 and company" across runway 4, the jet was a little over 100 feet above the ground, 12 seconds from touchdown. The truck started moving while the red runway entrance lights were still on. The controller then called "stop, stop, stop", but the firefighters did not realise it was meant for them. The truck had no transponder, so the tower's surface radar did not raise an alarm.
The aircraft hit the truck at about 104 mph. The captain and first officer were killed. Of the 76 people on board and two firefighters, 39 went to hospital and six were seriously injured. It was the first fatal crash at LaGuardia in 34 years.
The investigation is open and no probable cause has been set. The preliminary findings published so far focus on the clearance, the truck and the warning systems, not on the Jazz crew. For our score it still counts: a fatal accident in the last 15 years puts the accident record in the 60 to 79 band of our rubric. We put it at 74, near the top of that band, because the cause appears to lie largely with the clearance and the airport's warning systems.
Jazz's record before 2026
Before LaGuardia, Jazz had flown for 25 years without a fatal accident, with many thousands of short flights a year in some of Canada's worst weather. Two aircraft were Hull lossAn accident in which an aircraft is destroyed or damaged beyond economic repair. People may or may not be hurt.More in the glossary, neither with deaths:
- 20 May 2007, Toronto: a CRJ100 landed in a gusting crosswind of 13 to 23 knots, bounced and came down hard. Both main gear fittings failed, and the aircraft slid on its struts. Nobody was hurt.
- 10 May 2019, Toronto: a Dash 8-300 returning from Sudbury in bad weather collided with a fuel truck while taxiing to the gate at 1:25 a.m. The aircraft spun, and five people were injured. The TSB found that the tanker driver's view to the right was blocked by the truck's own equipment.
The event that worries us more is from November 2017. A Dash 8-400 landing at Toronto's Billy Bishop airport in gusty wind bounced and came down at more than 5.5 g, a force strong enough to stop both flight recorders. After a visual check by the crew, the aircraft flew back to Montreal. Only there did mechanics find damage to the rear fuselage and the right main gear. The TSB ran a limited investigation and did not publish a cause.
What does Jazz fly?
At the end of June 2026, Jazz flew 32 Dash 8-400 turboprops, 30 CRJ-900s and 25 Embraer E175s for Air Canada, according to Chorus Aviation's quarterly report. Seven older CRJ200s were parked. The Dash 8-400 and CRJ-900 are proven Canadian designs, but neither is Fly-by-wireA flight control system in which the pilot's inputs go to computers, which then move the control surfaces. Many such systems also stop unsafe manoeuvres.More in the glossary, and the fleet is getting smaller as aircraft leave the Air Canada contract. Jazz does not publish an average fleet age, so our fleet score is cautious.
Flying Air Canada Express
- Check "operated by" on the booking. Air Canada Express flights are run by Jazz or by PAL Airlines. Both are Canadian regional airlines under Transport Canada.
- Expect turboprops on short routes. Routes from Billy Bishop and many routes in eastern and western Canada use the Dash 8-400. It is slower and feels bumpier than a jet, which is a comfort matter, not a safety one.
- Winter brings cancellations. Small airports with limited approach aids close more often in snow and fog than Toronto or Montreal. A cancelled flight is better than a forced landing.
How we scored it
The LaGuardia accident sets the accident record at 74, and Transport Canada oversight scores 85, a little below Air Canada because we could not confirm Jazz's current IOSAThe IATA Operational Safety Audit, an international audit of an airline's safety management and operations. Every IATA member must pass it.More in the glossary entry. The fleet (68), the 2017 and 2019 incidents (76) and a network of tight and small airports (76) complete a score of 76.
Questions people ask
What happened to Air Canada flight 8646 at LaGuardia?
On 22 March 2026, Jazz flight 646, sold as Air Canada 8646 from Montreal, was landing on runway 4 just before midnight when it hit an airport fire truck crossing the runway on the way to another emergency. The captain and first officer died, and 39 people went to hospital. The NTSB says the controller cleared the truck to cross 12 seconds before touchdown; its final report is not out yet.
Is Jazz the same as Air Canada?
No. Jazz is owned by Chorus Aviation and flies under its own Transport Canada certificate with its own pilots, under a contract with Air Canada that runs to 2035. Its flights are sold with AC flight numbers and Air Canada Express branding. Air Canada also uses PAL Airlines for some Express routes.
Was the LaGuardia crash the pilots' fault?
Nothing published so far says so. The flight had a landing clearance, and the NTSB's preliminary report describes a crossing clearance given to the fire truck seconds before touchdown, runway warning lights the truck drove past, and a surface radar that gave no alert because the truck had no transponder. The final cause is for the NTSB to decide.
Is it safe to fly Air Canada Express?
Yes, the risk on any single flight is very small. Jazz flew for 25 years without a fatal accident before LaGuardia, and the cause there appears to lie largely outside the cockpit. If you want a jet rather than a turboprop, the aircraft type is shown at booking.
Sources
- 1.LaGuardia runway collision, Jazz Aviation flight 646 (DCA26MA161) (opens in a new tab) · NTSB, 2026
- 2.Firefighter heard 'stop, stop' before LaGuardia jet crash, but didn't know who it was for, NTSB says (opens in a new tab) · Associated Press via WCAX, 2026
- 3.Chorus Aviation Q2 2026 Management's Discussion and Analysis (fleet) (opens in a new tab) · Chorus Aviation, 2026
- 4.Air Canada 2025 Annual Information Form (Air Canada Express, Jazz CPA) (opens in a new tab) · Air Canada, 2026
- 5.ASN Wikibase 319435 – Jazz Dash 8-300 collision with fuel truck, Toronto, 10 May 2019 (opens in a new tab) · Aviation Safety Network, 2019
- 6.ASN Wikibase 319777 – Jazz Dash 8-400 hard landing, Toronto City, 9 November 2017 (opens in a new tab) · Aviation Safety Network, 2017
- 7.ASN Wikibase 321957 – Air Canada Jazz CRJ100, Toronto, 20 May 2007 (opens in a new tab) · Aviation Safety Network, 2007
- 8.Jazz Aviation LP successfully completes fifth consecutive IOSA safety audit (opens in a new tab) · Jazz Aviation, 2013