Is South African Airways safe?
South African Airways
South African Airways has had no fatal accident since the Helderberg fire in 1987. It came out of a 17-month business rescue in April 2021 as a much smaller airline of about 20 aircraft. Its regulator scores well with ICAO, but serious incidents since 2021, two of them in a single storm in May 2026, cost points.
#84of 120 airlines
Medium confidence- Last fatal accident
- Boeing 747 Combi Helderberg, flight SA295, near Mauritius, 28 November 1987 (159 deaths)
- Hull losses (last 20 years)
- None
- Business rescue
- December 2019 to April 2021; flights resumed 23 September 2021
- Fleet
- 18 own aircraft (14 A320-200s, 2 A330-300s, 2 A340-300s), December 2025
- Ownership
- South African state
- Regulator
- SACAA (FAA FAA IASAThe US FAA's check of whether a country's aviation regulator meets ICAO standards. Category 1 means it does; Category 2 means it does not.More in the glossary; about 95% in a 2026 ICAO validation)
- IOSA
- Registered (IATA member)
How the score breaks down
The overall score is the weighted average of these factors. Scoring rules
Accident record40% of score
88 out of 100, ExcellentNo fatal accident since 28 November 1987, when a fire in the main-deck cargo of 747 Combi Helderberg brought it down off Mauritius, killing all 159 (ASN 326653). The cause of the fire was never found. No SAA-operated aircraft has been Hull lossAn accident in which an aircraft is destroyed or damaged beyond economic repair. People may or may not be hurt.More in the glossary since.
Regulatory oversight20% of score
82 out of 100, GoodSouth Africa is in FAA IASAThe US FAA's check of whether a country's aviation regulator meets ICAO standards. Category 1 means it does; Category 2 means it does not.More in the glossary Category 1 (April 2025 list), and SACAA reported a preliminary 95% in a 2026 ICAO validation mission, up from 91% in 2023. SAA is an IATA member with IOSAThe IATA Operational Safety Audit, an international audit of an airline's safety management and operations. Every IATA member must pass it.More in the glossary. In 2021 SACAA held up a flight over crew currency and learned of a serious incident weeks late.
Fleet15% of score
65 out of 100, Fair18 aircraft of its own in December 2025 (ch-aviation, from SAA management): 14 leased A320-200s, two leased A330-300s and two owned A340-300s, plus wet-leased jets. No new-generation types; replacements are planned only from 2032. SAA publishes no fleet-age figure.
Serious incidents15% of score
62 out of 100, FairInvestigators blamed an A330 crew's autopilot handling and poor CRM for cabin crew injuries in October 2024. In May 2026 two A320s ran into a storm at Cape Town: one lost normal flight-control law, the other landed with 420 kg of fuel. An A340-600 had an Alpha Floor event in 2021.
Operating environment10% of score
68 out of 100, FairJohannesburg sits at 5,558 ft, Cape Town has winter storms with gusts above 50 knots, and the African network (Accra, Kinshasa, Lusaka, Harare and others) brings weaker infrastructure. In 2022 an A330 took on water-contaminated fuel at Accra.
Is South African Airways safe?
Yes, with caveats about the last few years. SAA has not had a fatal accident in almost 39 years, and South Africa's regulator, SACAA, is in the FAA's top category and scored about 95% in an ICAO validation mission in 2026. We score SAA 77, below Royal Air Maroc and above Kenya Airways.
The weaker part is what happened after 2019. SAA went through a 17-month business rescue, stopped flying, restarted with a handful of aircraft and has had a run of serious incidents since, including two on the same stormy morning at Cape Town in May 2026.
SAA's crash history
SAA's two deadliest accidents are decades old. On 20 April 1968 a Boeing 707 taking off from Windhoek on a moonless night levelled off at about 650 feet, began to descend and flew into the ground 5 km past the runway; 123 people died. Investigators blamed the human factor in very dark conditions.
On 28 November 1987 the Boeing 747 Combi Helderberg, flight SA295 from Taipei, had a fire in the main-deck cargo area over the Indian Ocean. The crew reported smoke and began an emergency descent towards Mauritius, but the aircraft broke up and crashed into the sea, killing all 159 people on board. The investigation could not find where the fire started, only that it may have disabled the crew, burned through control cables and weakened the structure.
Since then SAA has had no deaths and has not Hull lossAn accident in which an aircraft is destroyed or damaged beyond economic repair. People may or may not be hurt.More in the glossary an aircraft of its own. A 747SP owned by SAA was destroyed in 1998 by an uncontained engine failure, but Mozambique's LAM was operating it.
Business rescue and a smaller SAA
SAA entered business rescue in December 2019 and left it at the end of April 2021. It flew its first scheduled flight since then on 23 September 2021, three daily Johannesburg to Cape Town returns, with Accra, Kinshasa, Harare, Lusaka and Maputo next. By December 2025 it had 18 aircraft of its own, according to SAA management quoted by ch-aviation: 14 leased A320s, two leased A330-300s and two four-engined A340-300s. A wet-leased A330 from Hi Fly flies some routes, including Accra, Abidjan and Brazil. SAA plans to order 28 new-generation aircraft, but for delivery from 2032.
The airline remains state-owned and open to an equity partner. Its better 2024/25 result came largely from selling London Heathrow slots, and the Auditor-General issued a disclaimer of opinion on those accounts. We do not score finances, but long shutdowns matter for safety: in February 2021 SACAA at first refused to let SAA fly a vaccine charter to Brussels because its pilots were no longer current, and allowed it only after extra training.
Serious incidents since 2021
- Johannesburg, February 2021. On that vaccine flight, an A340-600 triggered Alpha Floor stall protection while retracting flaps after take-off, which may have been caused by a known software quirk with the take-off mass. SACAA said it was not told until 17 March, well past the reporting deadline.
- Over Botswana, April 2022. An A330-300 flew home from Accra with both engines surging all the way to Johannesburg. Fuel taken on at Accra the day before had been contaminated with water.
- Near Loxton, October 2024. An A330 at 41,000 feet hit clear-air turbulence and began oscillating in pitch while breakfast was served; three cabin crew were hurt, one seriously. Investigators found the pilot flying had disengaged the autopilot against Airbus guidance without telling the other pilot, and cited poor crew resource management.
- Cape Town, 11 May 2026. A storm hit Cape Town with gusts above 50 knots. One A320 went around in windshear, found it had too little fuel to try again, was turned away from George and landed at Port Elizabeth with 420 kg left, well below normal reserves. Three hours later another A320 hit windshear on approach; a flight-control computer fault dropped it into alternate and then direct law, and the crew landed it by hand. South Africa's investigators opened a serious-incident investigation into the second; SAA said it followed all required procedures, including incident reporting.
Who should be careful
- Fly SAA with normal confidence on its trunk routes, Johannesburg to Cape Town and Durban. Most of its recent events were weather and technical problems that crews handled.
- On Cape Town flights in winter (May to August), expect diversions when cold fronts come through. Allow spare time for connections.
- Keep your seat belt fastened in cruise. The 2024 injuries happened during meal service in clear air, with no weather on radar.
How we scored it
The accident record (88) is SAA's strength: no deaths since 1987. Oversight (82) reflects a strong national regulator and IOSAThe IATA Operational Safety Audit, an international audit of an airline's safety management and operations. Every IATA member must pass it.More in the glossary, less a few points for the 2021 currency and reporting problems. Incidents (62) cost the most, with four serious events since 2021 and crew findings in 2024. The small, older fleet (65) and a demanding African network (68) make up the rest. Overall 77.
Questions people ask
What happened to the Helderberg?
On 28 November 1987 SAA flight SA295, a Boeing 747 Combi carrying passengers and cargo on the main deck, was flying from Taipei to Mauritius when a fire broke out in the main-deck cargo area. The crew reported smoke and began an emergency descent, but the aircraft crashed into the Indian Ocean about 250 km from Mauritius, killing all 159 people on board. The source of the fire was never established.
Is SAA still flying after business rescue?
Yes. SAA was in business rescue from December 2019 to the end of April 2021 and stopped scheduled flying. It restarted on 23 September 2021 with three daily Johannesburg to Cape Town return flights, then added Accra, Kinshasa, Harare, Lusaka and Maputo. It has grown since but remains a much smaller airline.
Is SAA safer than FlySafair or Airlink?
We have not scored FlySafair or Airlink yet. All three are overseen by the same regulator, SACAA, which did well in ICAO's 2026 validation. SAA's record of no fatal accident since 1987 is strong; its recent serious incidents are the reason it does not score higher.
Does SAA's money trouble affect safety?
Not directly that we can see, but it is a reason to watch. The Auditor-General gave a disclaimer of opinion on the group's 2024/25 accounts, and the group CEO post was filled on an acting basis in April 2026. Finances do not change maintenance rules, but long periods of disruption can, as SACAA's 2021 concerns about pilot currency showed.
Sources
- 1.ASN Wikibase 326653 – SAA Boeing 747-244B Combi ZS-SAS Helderberg, flight SA295, 28 November 1987 (opens in a new tab) · Aviation Safety Network, 1987
- 2.ASN Wikibase 331864 – SAA Boeing 707 ZS-EUW, flight SA228, Windhoek, 20 April 1968 (opens in a new tab) · Aviation Safety Network, 1968
- 3.ASN Wikibase 460596 – SAA A330-343 ZS-SXJ, pitch oscillations near Loxton, 27 October 2024 (opens in a new tab) · Aviation Safety Network, 2024
- 4.South African Airways delays 2024/25 annual report (opens in a new tab) · ch-aviation, 2025
- 5.Poor audit at South African Airways blamed on state capture (opens in a new tab) · ch-aviation, 2026
- 6.SAA exits business rescue, resumes flights (opens in a new tab) · Travelweek, 2021
- 7.South African Airways' added leases delayed to 2026 (opens in a new tab) · ch-aviation, 2025
- 8.SA ranks eighth globally in world's safest aviation systems (opens in a new tab) · Business Day, 2026
- 9.IATA airline members list (South African Airways, SA/SAA) (opens in a new tab) · IATA, 2026
- 10.International Aviation Safety Assessment (IASA) program results (opens in a new tab) · FAA, 2025
- 11.SAA A320 at Cape Town on May 11th 2026, windshear and direct law degradation (opens in a new tab) · AeroInside, 2026
- 12.South African A320 at Cape Town, George and Port Elizabeth on May 11th 2026, landed below minimum fuel (opens in a new tab) · AeroInside, 2026
- 13.SAA A346 at Johannesburg on Feb 25th 2021, Alpha Floor activation on departure (opens in a new tab) · AeroInside, 2021
- 14.SAA A333 over Botswana on Apr 15th 2022, both engines surged until landing Johannesburg (opens in a new tab) · AeroInside, 2022